 |
|
Tuesday, September 20, 2005
The Kanye Comic Controversy.
The Kanye Comic Controversy.
And this is comical in more ways than one.
First, the background: an independent school newspaper from the University of Florida, the Independent Florida Alligator, ran a political cartoon in it's editorial section on Tuesday, September 13th featuring Kanye West showing Condoleeza Rice a "race card". Rice responds by saying "Nigga Please". The cartoonist is Andy Marlette, who's white and, judging from his defense of the cartoon and praise of Dr. Rice, is conservative. But it's created some noise on Florida's campus, which culminated into a protest on Friday afternoon.
This isn't anything new per se; the only difference is it's usually from the other end of the political spectrum. Leftist cartoonist Ted Rall's cartoon trashing Dr. Rice was several times worse, with Rice being a "parrot" on Bush's arm and admitting that she was a "house nigga". In the past year, Janice Rogers Brown and Colin Powell have been the targets of white liberals using racial stereotypes and insults in political cartoons. For the most part, you wouldn't hear a peep out of anyone other than conservatives about those cartoons.
However, black folks are up in arms at Florida. There's been the usual suspects, including the minority organization on campus, the school administrators, etc. On Friday, 50 students protested outside of the paper's offices (they weren't there, as they don't publish over the weekends) along with school administrators.
But as I said earlier, this is an independent school newspaper...one that Florida administrators can't touch because they aren't using school funds. They aren't affiliated with the University of Florida campus. And thus, they can afford to be a little edgy, and tick some more people off.
Here's their response to the protest:
Friday is the newsroom's day off work.
You see, we don't print a paper on Saturday.
But the Editorial Board hears that more than 50 students marched to our offices in protest of Tuesday's cartoon and its use of the word "nigga."
Several UF administrators joined the effort.
We weren't there, but we get the point.
And we agree that "nigga" is a word that shouldn't be floating around in our society. We agree the word should never appear in a news story. We agree that it does not represent all African Americans, by any stretch of the imagination.
But we're not going to apologize.
Instead, we want the administration, which has taken such a strong stance on the situation, to take a look at its own policies.
UF President Bernie Machen calls on us to print an apology because the cartoon "poison(s) the ongoing struggle to overcome the racial barriers that divide our country."
If we're reading this right, Machen wants us to retract any political commentary that propagates the use of, in his words, "damaging stereotypes."
Fair enough. We understand and respect that position, even if we disagree on whether the cartoon accomplished that.
So now we want Machen and administrators to follow through with their grand ambition.
In less than three weeks, Wayne Brady will grace the stage as the main performer for Gator Growl. He will be paid $65,000.
Not familiar with his work? Brady is a black comedian who uses "nigga" repeatedly in his stand-up.
And the administration approved his appearance at a pep rally that is arguably the most well-known event at UF.
Will UF officials protest an artist they are bringing here themselves? An artist who uses "nigga" in the same context as our cartoonist?
If Machen was willing to prohibit all alcohol advertisements in the Stephen C. O'Connell Center because they encouraged drinking, he should be willing to pull Brady because he's propagating the same "damaging stereotypes."
But he can't stop there. Brady is part of a trend.
Charlie Murphy should have never stepped on campus. "Nigga" flows from his mouth like the Mississippi River.
Kanye West himself will perform at the O'Connell Center soon. His lyrics are riddled with the word.
We want administrators to prove they don't want this kind of racist commentary within the university. Instead, they seem to be encouraging it. How irresponsible.
We have received many letters from students who resent the way these black performers use racist words. This doesn't represent their culture or their feelings on the issue. The entire black community does not use the word "nigga."
But a part of the community definitely does.
In fact, the first letter we received on the issue was from Black Student Union Treasurer Jeremy Watson. It turns out he is one of those who spreads it throughout society.
He is part of a Facebook group called N*ggas that Pledge.
We doubt he is racist. But if we spread it, then so does he.
Protesting the Alligator for printing a cartoon that depicts an existing cultural norm does not rid the world of that flaw.
We are the opinion section of a newspaper. We comment on societal norms and politics by pushing the envelope.
So to UF administrators: We're glad you have taken this opportunity to open up a discussion on the danger of the casual use of "nigga" in Gainesville and in the nation.
It means we've done our job.
Now run with the idea and actually take a stance.
Rather than focusing on a depiction of society, why don't you actually go out and protest the real thing? *chuckles* Yanno, Gator fans love to say, "Either you're a Gator, or you're Gator bait". Well I think Florida's administrators and minority dept should keep an eye open tonight for any gators traps on campus, because they got baited.
Don't mistake this for defending Marlette. Simply put, he's an idiot. I'm sure Dr. Rice would have some choice words for him too, considering the numerous times she's had to endure racial cartoons in the past five years, even if this was supposed to place her in a positive light, as Marlette alleges. And a simple Yahoo search shows that he's had problems with both Jews and Muslims in the past over his cartoons. The guy is just a low-class bombthrower.
However, the Alligator editorial board has now used this incident to place the ball in the court of Florida's administrators as well as the minority organizations. Are they going to stand up and call for an end to the double standard?
Doubt it. They'll probably pretend as if the editorial didn't exist.
Posted at 05:04 am by Expertise
 |  |  | Enrique Cardova October 2, 2005 09:11 PM PDT
gator power sez:
<b>the problem i see with the cartoon is the use of the race card. i find it horrible that white america continues to think that when someone says something is racist then it is automatically assumed
fictional or a joke. we don't question women everytime they call rape but when a person of color calls racism it is always questioned. there are many times when rape is thrown around in the wrong way and our society does everything it can to protect the victims as they should. but when it comes to race it is completely opposite.
as a graduate of the journalim school at UF and a current graduate student in the college of business i am glad the cartoon was printed because it shows sadly the diveristy problems at UF. the cartoon brings to light the good and bad of the racial enviroment at UF. It is great that now there are open discussions.</b>
All well and good to have discussions but does that change anything? Also a lot in this comment doesn't add up. For one thing the comparison between rape and commenting on race is totally different, although some "advocates" see no difference. Rape is a criminal matter, race opinion, is just that, a free speech opinion. Trying to draw some similarity is totally bogus.
Aslo white america doesn't automatically exempt people when something racistis said. In fact, white people are getting fired from some jobs for saying racist things, and even when they say things without any racial meaning they sometimes get fired, as the well known "niggardly" "slur" case shows
And people of color aren't automatically challenged when they call racism. That too is bogus. In fact the case is often quite the opposite. They actually get serious attention. Secretaries of State and even Presidents appear to reassure the nation. Then there is the flip side. Too often so-called "racism call-outs" are nothing but bogus posturing by people looking to run a hustle where they get paid (see jesse Jackson) or looking to get press attention (see Kanye West, Al Sharpton and others). They too often get a pass because they are black, and media coverage avoids asking hard questions for fear of appearing "insensitive."
Gator Power is glad these matters are sparking "open" discussion and will address "diversity" at UF. In fact they will do nothing of the sort. If this is the level of analysis (bogus comparisons and dubious assertions) being applied to the problem then there will be little understanding. Most students at UF, while politely mouthing platitudes and politely smiling will continue to be skeptical and quietly dismissive of would be "advocates" and black spokesmen on the subject of race. Don't let the polite expressions fool you. |  |
  |  |  | Gator September 25, 2005 02:39 AM PDT
"...you can only rob the word of its social negative power by accepting the word"
Wasn't that Marlette's idea? |  |
  |  |  | gator power September 23, 2005 02:48 AM PDT
well looks like we did not pretend the editional did not exist since people are contacting west's management and asking for him to refrain from using the word in his performance. looks like student government is pulling the advertising money from the paper. looks like some things are changing and it is about time because the alligator continues to cross the line of responsible journalism. is asking for an apology so bad? how hard is it for you to say sorry i hurt your feelings but that was not the intention? i do not expect marllett to understand the pain he has caused with numerous cartoons but i would have thought he would have at least stated he respected UF and was sorry for some of his works.
the problem i see with the cartoon is the use of the race card. i find it horrible that white america continues to think that when someone says something is racist then it is automatically assumed fictional or a joke. we don't question women everytime they call rape but when a person of color calls racism it is always questioned. there are many times when rape is thrown around in the wrong way and our society does everything it can to protect the victims as they should. but when it comes to race it is completely opposite.
as a graduate of the journalim school at UF and a current graduate student in the college of business i am glad the cartoon was printed because it shows sadly the diveristy problems at UF. the cartoon brings to light the good and bad of the racial enviroment at UF. It is great that now there are open discussions. |  |
  |  |  | Ryan September 21, 2005 02:35 PM PDT
This whole situation is just another classic example of how people like to bitch and complain about absolutely nothing. The irony of it is that the people who are complaining and protesting the most about it are the same people who this word probably doesn't really offend; there just taking a stance against it because they think they should. As a student at UF last year, I can't tell you how many times I heard the word "nigga" tossed around in general conversation. In fact, the word in itself is used more by black people, which ironically is the same race that the word should offend the most. Of course, not every black person uses this word, so there is no doubt that it will offend some people. But guess what? There's a lot of other crap in the world that offends people as well. Two years ago, some anti-abortion agency mailed thousands of fliers with a picture of an aborted baby on it. Honestly, it didn't offend me because I'm not easily offended, but I'm sure there were some people who were. You didn't hear half the outcry about that as you're hearing about this, and those fliers were mailed to people's houses. My point is that if people are wanting the Alligator to apologize, then they also must seek apologies from every other entity that has "offended" some group in some way. Let's also consider the double standard that exists by bringing an entertainer such as Kanye West to perform on campus where the word "nigga" will casually be spouted from his mouth. Will people become appalled and offended by his use of this word? Hell no. So before you start bitching and crying about something that supposedly "offends" you, think about the possible double standard you may be setting, because I can guarantee you that there are people up in arms over this who coincidentally will also be at Kanye's concert, singing his lyrics right along with him. |  |
  |  |  | RattlerGator September 21, 2005 12:11 PM PDT
The cartoonist is a grown-ass man who has grown up in a world where the popular music of the youth use the word incessantly. A world where Dave Chappelle is completely unafraid of tossing the term around, and he is not alone.
I laughed my ass off when I saw his “Niggar Family” routine on his Comedy Central show. I saved that video to my computer and later showed it to my wife. She was not amused. I also later showed it to my mother and her husband – they both were too polite to say it in vigorous terms – but neither one of them was amused.
But I’m sorry, that routine was funny as hell.
Nope, nope, nope – the arrogance spoken of by Booker Rising (among others, I'm sure) is with all of those “talented-tenth” Negroes who insist on banishing the word. Who insist on allowing white people to define what the word means; “talented-tenth” Negroes always, always, always find ways to empower white people while claiming to be assisting poorer, more ignorant Negroes who are just to stupid to figure out word usage for themselves.
Hell yeah, I use the word.
Hell yes, I’m a proud nigger.
And hell no, no damn fool is going to make me give up the word.
Though I have no hope they will soon figure this out, you can only rob the word of its social negative power by accepting the word – as the large majority of average African Americans surely have – and making it the powerful fraternal word that it, in fact, is. Crackers in Florida figured this out quite some time ago and the white equivalent of Nigger is now used throughout this state largely as a positive descriptor of a white Floridian of Southern heritage.
But the brilliantly insecure “talented-tenth” can’t figure that out and I’ve given up hoping they ever will. They apparently “need” to equip white people anywhere, any place with a yet another powerful weapon to sling against our children at any time or place of their choosing.
|  |
  |  |  | A Gator September 21, 2005 01:02 AM PDT
"They'll probably pretend as if the editorial didn't exist."
And there sits the problem.
I'm glad that the cartoon was printed, and I'm glad we're having this discussion. |  |
Home
|
|
 |